JK Rowling has criticised Labour frontbencher Lisa Nandy for her views on transgender points – describing her as “one of many greatest causes many ladies on the left now not belief Labour”.
The author made the outburst on X, previously often called Twitter, after the shadow worldwide growth secretary vowed throughout her Labour convention speech to face up for “girls’s rights”.
The Harry Potter writer questioned that supportraising earlier feedback Ms Nandy has made and a letter she signed backing the expulsion of Labour members who maintain “bigoted, transphobic views”.
Ms Rowling has been extremely important of Labour’s stance on trans points after Sir Keir Starmer stated “trans girls are girls”.
The newest row got here as Ms Nandy tweeted phrases from her speech stating: “Ladies’s rights are human rights and human rights are non-negotiable. My absolute precedence will probably be to embolden and empower girls and women in each a part of the world.”
A livid Ms Rowling tweeted: “You stated rapists must be transferred to girls’s prisons in the event that they self-identify as girls. You known as Lady’s Place UK a hate group.”
She added: “Given that you just’re one of many greatest causes many ladies on the Left now not belief Labour to defend their rights, do you stand by these feedback?”
The remark referred to remarks made by Ms Nandy on the 2020 Labour convention. “I consider very basically in folks’s rights to self-ID, and I consider the Gender Recognition Act strikes the flawed stability in relation to that,” she stated.
The Labour frontbencher added: “So crimes I believe which are recorded must be recorded as that individual needs, who has been via that course of, acquired help and self-identified. I believe trans girls are girls and I believe trans males are males so I believe they need to be within the jail of their selecting.”
Shadow worldwide growth secretary Lisa Nandy
(PA Archive)
Ms Nandy additionally signed a pledge card organised by the Labour Marketing campaign for Trans Rights that stated celebration members who maintain “bigoted, transphobic views” must be expelled.
It additionally known as Lady’s Place UK – a bunch that opposes gender self-identification for transgender folks – as a “trans-exclusionist hate group”.
However the senior Labour MP additionally stated: “Do I believe that girls within the Labour celebration who elevate questions on it must be expelled? No I don’t.”
When requested in regards to the subject on Sky Information on 2020, Ms Nandy stated: “I’ve to say, that was the a part of the pledge that gave me pause for considered whether or not to signal it.”
“I made a decision to signal it in the long run as a result of I believe that the sentiment of the pledge about defending trans rights and about accepting that trans males are males and trans girls are girls is actually vital, particularly in the meanwhile with the extent of discrimination that folks face.”
She added: “I don’t assume that proscribing organisations is definitely the precise approach to take care of disciplinary points within the Labour celebration.”
Sir Keir was attacked by Ms Rowling for saying present UK legislation meant that transgender girls can already be thought-about girls.
Requested to outline what a girl is, Sir Keir informed The Occasions: “A girl is a feminine grownup, and along with that trans girls are girls, and that isn’t simply my view – that’s truly the legislation.”
Rowling took to Twitter to assert Sir Keir “publicly misrepresents equalities legislation”, saying it was “yet one more indication that the Labour Get together can now not be counted on to defend girls’s rights”.
